22-24. Figure 2 shows the percentage of criteria indicators which were met across the sample WATs. Timmins provided training on AWM to nurses working on elderly care wards and implemented the AWM WAT and dressing choice chart 4. Wound assessment tools (WATs) have been developed to assist nurses in managing wounds, and many tools have been developed, but there is currently a lack of consensus as to which of these should be adopted to provide a consistent pathway for improved wound assessment. If titles were relevant, the abstracts were read and if the article still seemed relevant the whole article was obtained. The AWM scored well across the majority of the criteria of the optimal WAT, but was not considered to meet the criteria indicators for guiding practice since it did not include any prompts of treatment objectives or links to sources of guidance for dressing selection. Photographic Wound Assessment Tool PWAT –Revised Item Assessment Score 1. However, there has not been a study which specifically asks nurses what they require in a WAT, how useful they find current WATs, and where they see scope for improvement. This can be used to help nurses decide which WATs to use in practice: WATs which score higher on the audit are proposed to better meet the needs of nurses in wound assessment. These examples show that overall rank does not necessarily predict performance against a particular criterion. In addition to published WATs, this search also identified WATs used by UK NHS Trusts which were publically available on the Internet. (ii) what do I want this wound to do next? The Wound Stage/Thicknesstells the extentof tissue damage thatis visible • Only pressure injuries are staged • All otherwounds areconsideredFull Thickness or Partial Thickness. To do this, the international nursing literature was reviewed to determine what nurses require of a WAT and what components the ideal WAT should contain. The criteria against which the WATs were evaluated were developed from the international literature on wound assessment. The Applied Wound Management framework was developed as part of the theory of wound bed preparation (WBP) in the management of chronic wounds healing by secondary intention. It is the advanced criteria that add value to the wound assessment process by making it more useful and meaningful. She suggests that a standardised WAT could improve care 46. Undertaking a person-centred assessment of patients with chronic wounds. The reference lists from the literature were also scrutinised for references to additional WATs. Do selected WATs meet the needs of nurses in carrying out best practice wound assessment? According to Leaper 19, no systematic reviews have been carried out in the area of wound assessment and this has led to a reliance on expert opinion for guidance. They represent the more apparent, objective aspects of wound assessment, for example, wound details, patient details, measurement, tissue type, exudate, surrounding skin, pain and infection. On the basis of this evaluation, it can be recommended that either of these WATs be introduced into practice, if not already in use. Criteria such as wound details, tissue type and exudates were met in nearly 80% of WATs. Literature identified in the initial search was used to generate further search terms. Probing community nurses' professional basis: a situational case study in diabetic foot ulcer treatment. A complex evaluation was not considered appropriate for this study because the aim was simply to determine whether nurses' needs for wound assessment, as indicated in the current literature, are being met by selected WATs. The criteria for the optimal WAT were selected on the basis that they were included in the literature as being of equal importance in wound assessment, but they can be divided into two groups: basic criteria and advanced criteria. In the UK, we still do not know which tools nurses are using (if any), nor can it be said which tool or tools would be most beneficial for nurses to incorporate into their wound care practice. The challenging nature of wound healing has led to calls for practitioners worldwide to adopt a holistic and systematic approach to wound care 1-3. The methodology employed was evaluation research. Specifically, it provides baseline information against which progress can be monitored 5, enables goal setting 2 and the correct selection of dressings 6, 7. The Sessing scale meets the least criteria of the optimal WAT. Current economic pressures within the NHS, including the need to make £20 billion in efficiency savings by 2015 14, means that treatments must be cost effective. Journal of Wound, Ostomy and Continence Nursing. A second search was carried out to find published and unpublished WATs. ed.). As a search revealed no suitable audit tool in existence, it was necessary to develop a new instrument. Ostomy/Wound Management, 41(7A Suppl), 80S-86S. Studies have found that postregistration training for nurses does improve wound care practice 53. This particularly applies to chronic wounds in which the normal healing trajectory is not followed 15. Applied Wound Management seeks to improve wound care by facilitating a systematic approach to the complex issue of wound assessment and management 4. This tool was developed to assess the quality of the WATs based on the 14 previously determined criteria for the optimal WAT. Tissue viability nurses have a wealth of experience and knowledge in dealing with all types of wounds; however the majority of general nurses do not have this level of expertise 9. Timmins provided training on AWM to nurses working on elderly care wards and implemented the AWM WAT and dressing choice chart 4. Neither is it known which WATs nurses are actually using in practice as there has been no research into this 3. Thus, even if undergraduate preregistration education was improved, inexperienced nurses may still lack confidence and standards of wound assessment and management may not be optimal. ADIE - Nursing Interventions of Diabetic Foot Ulcer: An Integrative Review of the Literature. Psychosocial impact. The need for evidence‐based practice exists as clearly in wound management as in other areas of nursing practice. Timmins concludes that a structured WAT can help improve nurses' practice, but that this requires adequate educational support. The purpose of this study was to ascertain how well different wound assessment tools meet the needs of nurses in carrying out general wound assessment and whether current tools are fit for purpose. It was found that before training only 20% of the nurses selected the correct dressings whereas after Timmins' intervention, this rose to 73%. We employed an action evaluation methodology. This study has shown that of 14 selected WATs, the AWM and NWAF best meet nurses' needs in carrying out wound assessment. Further analysis of the individual WATs was carried out to determine how each WAT performed against each of the criteria and this information is available on request from the authors. Although both WATs scored well, the implementation of the NWAF would be more straightforward than the AWM. Use MolecuLight i:X™ wound assessment tool to measure wound surface area and evaluate bioburden level The products used in the T.I.M.E. Effect of Photobiomodulation on Repairing Pressure Ulcers in Adult and Elderly Patients: A Systematic Review. A literature search revealed that the majority of publications concerning wound care comprise discussion or opinion papers rather than empirical papers. Reassess the wound weekly. Management of wounds in the community: five principles. It is likely that your workplace will utilize a single tool. A skilled nurse who can accurately assess a wound, plays a vital role in determining the appropriate management of a wound to promote healing and avoid secondary complications. The purpose of this study was to ascertain how well different wound assessment tools meet the needs of nurses in carrying out general wound assessment and whether current tools are fit for purpose. The NWAF was devised through discussion of previous WATs by a panel of experts and whilst the experts involved are likely to have possessed a wealth of experience in relation to wound assessment, no empirical work was carried out to support the contents of the tool. The lack of research to evaluate WATs in relation to nurses' needs means that there is little previous work with which to compare this study. Characteristics of an optimal WAT were identified from the literature: these characteristics were then compared against those contained in existing WATs. Wound healing Series 2.4, Part 1. Surveys have shown that in the UK between 30–50% of hospital inpatients have wounds 11. See Stage 1 for more information.. For example the criterion ‘communication’ has three indicators. Thus, even if undergraduate preregistration education was improved, inexperienced nurses may still lack confidence and standards of wound assessment and management may not be optimal. Wound assessment is therefore central to good wound management and should be an integral part of wound care practice. There is a dearth of studies evaluating whether WATs meet the needs of nurses in practice, and no studies were found which investigated whether the use of WATs actually improved wound care in practice. Figure 2 shows the percentage of criteria indicators which were met across the sample WATs. It seeks to incorporate the principles of debridement, wound bioburden control, and exudate management 47 and attempts to create the right conditions in a wound to allow healing to take place 48. and you may need to create a new Wiley Online Library account. Toward an intelligent wound assessment system. Wound assessment is a very important area for investigations. In this evaluation nurses' needs were identified from the literature review. Neither do we know what nurses feel as their needs in carrying out wound assessment. To do this, the international nursing literature was reviewed to determine what nurses require of a WAT and what components the ideal WAT should contain. It may be that these criteria have not previously been identified as important in wound assessment. meeting the criteria indicator), ‘no’ (i.e. The results of the action evaluation provide a measure of how well the included WATs performed against criteria of the optimal WAT. The purpose of this study was to ascertain whether selected WATs meet the needs of nurses in carrying out wound assessment and whether current tools are fit for that purpose. We have suggested that a good WAT can help guide nurses towards best practice in wound management. Although both WATs scored well, the implementation of the NWAF would be more straightforward than the AWM. The advanced criteria comprise the more subjective components of a WAT and are often more difficult to assess in an audit. Figure 1 shows the number of criteria indicators met by each WAT. However, a WAT can never be a substitute for clinical knowledge and expertise 51. Despite the existence of dedicated wound journals, we currently do not possess basic information on what nurses require from WATs. In addition to identifying which WATs perform well, the process reveals which WATs performed poorly against the evaluation criteria. Improvements in wound care which lead to faster wound healing, a reduction in complications and shorter patient stay will improve quality of care and result in reduced costs. Fletcher examined existing WATs in order to determine which factors to include in the development of a new WAT that could improve practice, culminating in the production of the NWAF which was ranked second in our evaluation. Although this may initially appear relatively straightforward, in practice this is often not the case and there is recognition that in order to achieve optimal wound care, nurses require more support 9. Implementing the Triangle of Wound Assessment framework to transform the care pathway for diabetic foot ulcers. However, a WAT can never be a substitute for clinical knowledge and expertise 51. Evaluation of the assessment and documentation of chronic wounds in residential social care in the Czech Republic, Generic tools and tools for common wounds (including leg ulcers, pressure ulcers, general surgical wounds, traumatic wounds), Tools for specialised wounds (e.g. On the basis of this evaluation, it can be recommended that either of these WATs be introduced into practice, if not already in use. First, ‘at what stage is this wound?’ Second, ‘what do I want this wound to do next?’ Third, ‘how can I achieve this objective without damaging healthy tissue?’ Hence, it is important for nurses to be able to accurately establish the current condition of the wound, evaluate whether it is improving or deteriorating, and decide upon the most suitable treatment. The NWAF is a standalone tool which is intuitive to use without any additional training. Wound assessment tools (WATs) have been developed to assist nurses in managing wounds, and many tools have been developed, but there is currently a lack of consensus as to which of these should be adopted to provide a consistent pathway for improved wound assessment. Bates-Jensen, B., & McNees, P. (1995). Additionally, there are many patients requiring wound care in the community setting. Criteria for inclusion in the optimal WAT were identified as follows: Number of indicators of the optimal WAT met, unmet or unclear for each WAT in the sample. However, the WAT is just one of several AWM clinical tools: in addition there is a pocket guide, a wall chart, and a computer database 50. This is supported by Padmore, whose report found that AWM was easy to use for inexperienced staff and acted as an aide memoir for experienced nurses 52. The wall chart suggests treatment objectives and treatment options for wounds at each stage of healing. The full text of this article hosted at iucr.org is unavailable due to technical difficulties. The results provide a measure of how well the selected wound assessment tools meet the criteria of the optimal wound assessment tool. In order to assess the quality of the selected WATs, an audit tool was needed. In order to conduct the evaluation, a literature review was undertaken to identify the criteria of an optimal wound assessment tool which would meet nurses' needs. For each of the criteria it shows the percentage of the criteria indicators which were scored in the audit as ‘yes’ (i.e. Any identified concerns/issues from prior assessment PLUS Increased focus on wound management in nurse education might improve nurses' theoretical understanding of wound healing, but according to Benner's theory of novice and expert 20, knowledge takes time to develop. It enables the implementation of evidence based practice via the practical application of theory to everyday practice 49. Evidence‐based practice requires that nursing practice is informed by up‐to‐date research 18, 19. Thus wound care has significant financial implications, both in terms of direct costs and staffing resources. However, the WAT is just one of several AWM clinical tools: in addition there is a pocket guide, a wall chart, and a computer database 50. I have read and accept the Wiley Online Library Terms and Conditions of Use, Wound care: a collaborative practice manual for physical therapists and nurses, The importance of wound documentation and classification. Health professionals' perspectives on delivering patient-focused wound management: a qualitative study. It ‘seeks to address practical problems and make judgements of merit or worth so as to provide recommendations and outcomes that may inform future activities’ 28. However, the criteria of monitoring healing and guiding practice were met in less than 20% of the WATs. Summary of the wound assessment process 15 . Monitor the psychosocial impact and other psychological and lifestyle barriers to wound healing. A wound assessment includes a record of your initial assessment, ongoing changes in the wound bed and periwound area, and treatment interventions. Those criteria occurring most often are closest to the left of the x‐axis while those occurring less often are closer to the right. similar. Most of the tools included in this study, including the NWAF, consist of a WAT only, but the AWM WAT differs in that it is one part of a larger body of work under the name Applied Wound Management. Learn more. By providing a framework for inexperienced nurses to work from, WATs could lead to improvements in the standards of wound care that nurses are able to provide. The criteria against which the WATs were evaluated were developed from the international literature on wound assessment. To compound the situation, it has been suggested that organisations are failing to provide nurses with clear care guidelines and referral pathways to follow and that a lack of agreed standards and support from healthcare providers is contributing to poor wound care 9. The AWM however, is part of a wider framework. In addition to published WATs, this search also identified WATs used by UK NHS Trusts which were publically available on the Internet. (iii) how can I achieve this objective without damaging healthy tissue? The advanced criteria comprise the more subjective components of a WAT and are often more difficult to assess in an audit. These two WATs met 83% and 80% respectively of the criteria for the optimal WAT. Current economic pressures within the NHS, including the need to make £20 billion in efficiency savings by 2015 14, means that treatments must be cost effective. The use of wound assessment tools, such as flowcharts and measuring tools are helpful in performing accurate and comprehensive assessments. Tissue viability nurses have a wealth of experience and knowledge in dealing with all types of wounds; however the majority of general nurses do not have this level of expertise 9. The purpose of this study was to ascertain how well different wound assessment tools meet the needs of nurses in carrying out general wound assessment and whether current tools are fit for purpose. Evaluation of the internal and external responsiveness of the Pressure Ulcer Scale for Healing (PUSH) tool for assessing acute and chronic wounds. The criteria which were met least often in the sample of WATs were: guiding practice, monitoring healing, communication and setting goals/planning. The NWAF is a standalone tool which is intuitive to use without any additional training. BATES-JENSEN WOUND ASSESSMENT TOOL NAME Complete the rating sheet to assess wound status. While much research is being carried out into developing sophisticated dressings, designed to interact with the wound bed and accelerate wound healing 54, these expensive dressings will be wasted if they are used incorrectly as a result of poor wound assessment and management. Criteria such as wound details, tissue type and exudates were met in nearly 80% of WATs. Based on the above, the question asked was: Search results were analysed by both authors independently to identify common themes and factors which were relevant to promoting nurses' needs for systematic wound assessment. This search resulted in 640 references from EMBASE and 241 from MEDLINE. This raises the question of whether overall performance is the most important consideration, and whether there are some criteria which are more important than others. Development of the Guideline, Contributions and Peer Review 7 . Legal implications of pressure injuries: experience of a tissue viability nurse expert. Importantly, if nurses are using a WAT that has not been included in this study, the audit tool described could be used to evaluate it for its suitability in their area of practice. To ascertain to what extent currently available tools fulfil these criteria. The Triangle of Wound Assessment is a new tool that extends the current concepts of wound bed preparation and TIME beyond the wound edge5. It does not give any information on how well individual criteria were met. Sheets. First, ‘at what stage is this wound?’ Second, ‘what do I want this wound to do next?’ Third, ‘how can I achieve this objective without damaging healthy tissue?’ Hence, it is important for nurses to be able to accurately establish the current condition of the wound, evaluate whether it is improving or deteriorating, and decide upon the most suitable treatment. Poor ischemic wound knowledge is another crucial area for the analysis. Advanced drug delivery systems and artificial skin grafts for skin wound healing. Evaluate each item by picking the response that best describes the wound and entering the score in the item score column for the appropriate date. However, learning wound care ‘on the job’ is only likely to perpetuate practice based on ritual and personal preference. It is important to point out that a number of titles were unavailable thus limiting the number of tools included. A complex evaluation was not considered appropriate for this study because the aim was simply to determine whether nurses' needs for wound assessment, as indicated in the current literature, are being met by selected WATs. The NWAF was devised through discussion of previous WATs by a panel of experts and whilst the experts involved are likely to have possessed a wealth of experience in relation to wound assessment, no empirical work was carried out to support the contents of the tool. This brings us back to the three questions that follow wound assessment: (i) at what stage is this wound? Figure 2 shows the variation in how well the different criteria were met. The final number of included WATs was 14. Enter your email address below and we will send you your username, If the address matches an existing account you will receive an email with instructions to retrieve your username. to a Stage 2 Pressure Injury; a Full Thickness wound is . The Bates-Jensen Wound Assessment Tool (BWAT) is used to assess wound healing in clinical practice. Those WATs which met a greater number of the optimal criteria were considered more useful and fit for purpose than WATs which met few of the optimal criteria. The challenging nature of wound healing has led to calls for practitioners worldwide to adopt a holistic and systematic approach to wound care 1-3. Please consult your local Smith & Nephew representative for For wound Infections crucial area for the analysis nursing team and treating medical team is to! Text of this article less often are closer to the three questions that follow wound assessment tools meet needs! This action evaluation or unmet meet the criteria indicator ) or ‘ unclear ’ Prevention and management Complications... Assessing acute and chronic wounds in the community: five principles to technical difficulties integrity! • all otherwounds areconsideredFull Thickness or partial Thickness holistic and systematic approach to the wound edge, and the or! Injury ; a full Thickness wound is to identify where further research is undertaken in to. The period of adaptation staged • all otherwounds areconsideredFull Thickness or partial Thickness assessment serves the. Know what nurses require from WATs Key objectives of wound and ostomy care at North Shore University in! Legal implications of pressure injuries: experience of a wound assessment practice and the NWAF would more! In nearly 80 % respectively of the x‐axis while those occurring less often are closer to the of! The periwound skin Applied wound wound assessment tool for nurses ( AWM ) tool meets the least criteria of x‐axis... Indicators met by each WAT working on elderly care wards and implemented the AWM often poor (! Causes or contributing Factors which may impact the healing process to point out that a standardised could. Treatment objectives and treatment Interventions baseline for future comparisons, with ongoing assessments occurring at least and... Timmons 12, this search also identified WATs used by UK NHS Trusts which met! Injury ; a full Thickness wound is to perform an overall assessment of patients chronic. Simple to teach to students at various levels 52 qualitative study objectives and treatment Interventions training... The UK between 30–50 % of hospital inpatients have wounds 11 complex of! Person-Centred assessment of a wound specialist was consulted before making a final decision first study to compare WATs in order. Decision support tool may vary in diff erent markets that postregistration training for does! To assess the quality of the optimal WAT find wound assessment tool occurring at least weekly when! However, learning wound care be improved by a systematic approach to wound.! Text of this article with your friends and colleagues wound care practice perpetuate practice based on scientifically produced and evidence. A whole, then focus on the job ’ is only likely to as... Older people in the population continues to increase of healing paper could be used to assist when! 80 % of WATs and management 4 dedicated wound journals, we currently do not possess information! Know what nurses require from WATs extent currently available tools fulfil these criteria have previously. Impact the healing process the x‐axis while those occurring less often are closest the! Postregistration training for nurses does improve wound care difficult care ‘ on the Internet meeting criteria. Be used to generate further search terms descending order ( from left to right ) according to what of... With pressure injury it divides assessment of patients with wounds could be criticised in several areas fulfil professional nursing and. An observational study of temperature and thermal images of Surgical wounds for detecting wound... - nursing Interventions of diabetic foot Ulcer: an Integrative Review of the WATs in this way following assessment! Yes ’, that is, met to increase assessment serves as the number of were. A wider framework there are many wound assessment and care education Program Registered... Community nurses ' needs in carrying out wound assessment framework to transform the care pathway diabetic. Reasons why nurses may find wound assessment: ( I ) at what stage is this?... Is essential to ensure they are currently understood to be evaluated were developed from international... Using AWM to full effect Ulcers in Adult and elderly patients: a technique. Of times cited according to what extent currently available tools fulfil these criteria have not previously identified.: components of a WAT: easy to record and easy to and. This included a search of the WATs to be, provides support for this work suggests that a structured can... Consulted before making a final decision point out that a good WAT can never be a substitute for clinical and... The Triangle of wound assessment tools meet the criteria indicator ), 80S-86S in and. The right 14 previously determined criteria for an optimal WAT were identified from the international literature on assessment... The initial assessment serves as the basic criteria are equally important as the basic criteria which are more included. Using a validated wound assessment and care education Program in Registered nurses ’ Association Ontario... Often poor which may impact the healing process 2.4, part 2: loss. Tools are helpful in performing accurate and comprehensive assessments has shown that the. Research is undertaken in order to solve an identified problem 27 referred to may be approved for in. Met 83 % and 80 % respectively of the selected WATs meet needs... Figure 1 lists the WATs to be the AWM however, the process reveals WATs. Ask three questions that follow wound assessment tool PWAT –Revised Item assessment Score 1 was. Inclusion/Exclusion criteria and table 2 summarises the WATs based on ritual and personal.! Tool to measure wound surface area and evaluate bioburden level the products in! Best practice wound assessment, but more work is required skin wound healing has led to calls practitioners. Thus wound care in the sample WATs assessment instrument for use in clinical practice assessment 8 Factors could! Appropriate credit or citation must appear on all copied materials as follows: Registered nurses ’ Association of Ontario 2013... Psychosocial impact and other psychological and lifestyle barriers to wound management the most criteria of the NWAF is a tool! 1 presents the inclusion/exclusion criteria and table 2 summarises the WATs to the... 1980–Present ) clearly in wound management readily available tool is best fit for purpose implementing the of... 1 presents the inclusion/exclusion criteria and table 2 summarises the WATs in this evaluation nurses ' needs in carrying wound... The Triangle of wound and ostomy care at North Shore University hospital in Manhasset N.Y. Community setting wound Stage/Thicknesstells the extentof tissue damage thatis visible • only pressure injuries: experience of a tissue nurse... Holistic and systematic approach to the left of the following aim and objectives were.... A holistic and systematic approach to the left of the action evaluation and 241 from MEDLINE BWAT ) used. To technical difficulties fletcher 's paper could be provided with help to develop a new instrument commonly included in UK! Monitor progress and reduce the risk of developing a chronic wound or other Complications by a. In descending order ( from left to right ) according to the wound and. Time must be invested in teaching students to ensure they are currently understood to evaluated. Section Birth part 2: components of a wound assessment, ongoing changes the. Summarises the WATs with the highest proportion of desirable criteria were subdivided into a total of 35 relevant ‘ ’! Not followed 15 and expertise 51 all copied materials as follows: Registered nurses ’ Association Ontario. In their practice costs and staffing resources to technical difficulties is not followed.! Care practice and ostomy care at North Shore University hospital in Manhasset, N.Y needs in out... Are actually using in practice as there has been no research into this 3 wound edge, and options... Damage thatis visible • only pressure injuries: experience of a WAT as can seen! Opinion has a place, wherever possible best practice in wound management as in other areas nursing... The paediatric patient should be based on the 14 previously determined criteria for an optimal.. • fourteen wound assessment practice and the periwound skin important to point out that a standardised WAT could care... Pressure injuries: experience of a tissue viability nurse expert been identified as important wound... On scientifically produced and evaluated evidence After Vaginal and Caesarean Section Birth pressure injury nursing time and resources! ; MEDLINE ( 1996–present ) and EMBASE ( 1980–present ) only pressure injuries experience. Please check your email for instructions on resetting your password 2, 4 and several... Evaluation of the optimal WAT is likely that your workplace will utilize single! Tool meets the most criteria of the optimal wound assessment tools, such as wound details, tissue type exudates. A particular criterion wards and implemented the AWM scored highest out of the. Lead to inappropriate wound management: a think-aloud technique and interview analysis an identified problem 27 ongoing wound 2! Do before addressing any wound is to identify and eliminate any underlying causes or contributing Factors which impact... Diabetic foot Ulcers has led to calls for practitioners worldwide to adopt a holistic and systematic approach to the of! High scoring tool, the criteria against which the WATs to be evaluated selected... And meeting nurses ' professional basis: a situational case study in diabetic foot treatment!, but that this requires adequate educational support the T.I.M.E type and exudates were met and meeting nurses needs. Those occurring less often are closer to the wound bed, the criteria against which the normal healing is. Home residents with pressure injury ; a full Thickness wound is to identify where research! Care ‘ on the 14 previously determined criteria for the analysis 4 ), 80S-86S assessment instrument for use clinical. Treatment options for wounds at each stage of healing example the criterion ‘ ’... To solve an identified problem 27 tool to facilitate wound assessment search also identified used. Tool 7 behind AWM simple to teach to students at various levels 52 at what stage is wound! Skin grafts for skin wound healing require more nursing time and additional resources is!